Why 50% of Homes Are Selling for Under Asking and How To Avoid It

Why 50% of Homes Are Selling for Under Asking and How To Avoid It If your selling strategy still assumes you’ll get multiple offers over asking, it’s officially time for a reset. That frenzied seller

*December 09, 2025 | 4 min read*

Here in Rockwall, TX selling strategy still banks on multiple offers over asking, it’s time for a reality check. The intense seller’s market is over, and local data proves it.

From Frenzy Back to Normal Home Sales

Right now, about 50% of homes across the U.S. — and even higher in some Rockwall neighborhoods — are selling below asking price, per the latest Cotality reports. But this isn’t doom and gloom; it’s a return to a balanced market after years of unsustainable hype.

Zillow data shows the shift clearly:
– 2018–2019: 50–55% sold under asking (the historical norm)
– 2021–2022: Only 25% under, fueled by low rates and buyer frenzy
– 2025: Back to 50% under asking, aligning with typical trends

In Rockwall, TX, where luxury homes dominate lakefront and gated communities, this means buyers have more leverage than they’ve had in years.

Why Pricing Matters More Than Ever for Rockwall Sellers

Gone are the days of overpricing and watching bids roll in. Today’s Rockwall buyers — many relocating for the lifestyle, schools, and proximity to Dallas — have options, stricter budgets, and no rush.

Your initial asking price is critical. The first two weeks on market attract the most serious buyers. Price too high, and your listing stalls, leading to price cuts and longer days on market (currently averaging 78–79 in Rockwall County).

Sellers sticking to outdated expectations face reductions, lowball offers, and extended timelines. But those who adapt are still closing at or above asking — especially for well-prepped luxury homes in Rockwall.

The Winning Formula for Selling in Rockwall, TX

As a top Rockwall, TX Realtor specializing in luxury homes, we’ve helped sellers net top dollar even in this market. Here’s how:

1. **Prep Your Home Thoroughly**
Address repairs, updates, and staging upfront. For luxury homes in Rockwall — think waterfront estates or acreage properties — pristine condition can command premiums and multiple offers.

2. **Price Strategically from Day One**
Skip relying on list prices; use recent sold comps from neighborhoods like Stone Creek, The Preserve, or Heath’s lakefront areas. Our data-driven approach as Rockwall’s #1 team ensures you hit the sweet spot.

3. **Stay Flexible on Negotiations**
Expect give-and-take on closing costs, repairs, or concessions — not just price. Serious buyers in Rockwall, TX anticipate this, and it can seal the deal without slashing your bottom line.

Bottom Line for Rockwall Sellers

Half of homes sell under asking because the market has normalized — but the other half succeed with smart strategy. Don’t plan for yesterday’s frenzy; align with today’s reality.

As your Rockwall, TX Realtor for luxury homes, 2A Realty Group delivers the local expertise to get your property noticed and sold strong.

Want to know your home’s true value in this market?

📞 **Contact 2A Realty Group today** — (469) 380-7433
🌐 **2ARealtyGroup.com**
📧 Jorge@2ARealtyGroup.com

*KW Luxury Official | KW Sports + Entertainment | Serving Rockwall, Heath, Fate, Royse City, and Broken Bow, OK*

Jorge Avila

Love Jesus, Love People | 8x Father | Designing his services on a foundation of authenticity, transparency and above all, integrity, Jorge Avila is a highly accredited Realtor who aims to make transactions fun, inviting, and seamless for everyone involved. Jorge features an extensive background within this industry and has cultivated a deep understanding of the buying, selling, negotiating, and local marketing processes that guarantee a positive experience for every one of his clients.
 

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message